Nestled on Sheffield Road in Rotherham, Goodfellas Restaurant offers a well-rounded menu that blends traditional Italian favourites with crowd-pleasing international comfort food. The Goodfellas Restaurant Menu caters to a diverse clientele, ranging from families to casual diners seeking generous portions and approachable flavours.
A standout starter is the Garlic Mushrooms, served in a rich creamy sauce with warm bread - a simple but satisfying choice that sets the tone for the meal. Pasta enthusiasts will appreciate the Spaghetti Carbonara, featuring al dente noodles coated in a velvety egg-based sauce with pancetta, while the Lasagne Al Forno arrives bubbling with layers of meat, pasta, and béchamel that feel authentically rustic.
The pizza selection is expansive and hearty. The Goodfellas Special Pizza, topped with pepperoni, ham, mushrooms, and onions, is both indulgent and balanced, while vegetarians can opt for the Vegetarian Supreme, generously layered with peppers, sweetcorn, mushrooms, and olives. Meat lovers might gravitate toward the Ribeye Steak, cooked to order and served with chunky chips and peppercorn sauce - a clear nod to British steakhouse traditions.
What sets Goodfellas apart is not just the range of dishes but the portion sizes, which are notably large and ideal for sharing. This value-for-money approach gives the restaurant an edge over more minimalist Italian bistros. Desserts like the Tiramisu and Chocolate Fudge Cake round off the experience with familiar, comforting sweetness.
Located at 53 Sheffield Rd, Rotherham, S60 1DA, the venue boasts a casual ambiance and friendly service. It’s not aiming for high-end dining, but rather consistent, hearty meals that keep customers returning. Whether you're in the mood for pasta, pizza, or a classic grill option, Goodfellas delivers reliable flavours with no pretense - a solid local favourite for relaxed dining.